Except that when Madoka reaches out to Homura's soul gem Homura goes HA HA JUST AS PLANNED and grabs her
The soul gem turns blacker than all of the witches' curses and Homura steals part of Madoka's world-remaking powers. QB is afraid and asks what the fuck is that black shit and Homura replies IT'S LOVE. Also if Madoka is a god then Homura is the devil. QB goes "holy shit you humans are fucking scary I'm getting the fuck out of here" but she grabs him and says from now on he's working for her and remakes the world.
In the new world all the girls are alive and human again. Sayaka confronts Homura and starts to summon her witch like a stand but Homura just makes it disappear and goes all "you're going to forget everything anyway" and five seconds later that's precisely what happens.
At the school this time it's Madoka who's the transfer student. She was in America for three years because her mother was transferred there and they just got back to Japan. During lunch break Homura drags her out saying she'll show her around the school, and in that one long corridor Madoka starts to regain some of her memories and powers, but Homura stops her. She then confronts Madoka and asks if order is really all that important. Madoka's answer is that yeah it's selfish and wrong to break the rules just for yourself. Homura returns the red ribbon to her, and says that if that's the case, eventually they may turn out to be enemies.